The threat of the COVID-19 pandemic extends beyond the spread of infectious disease, high rates of unemployment, and economic recession. The coronavirus outbreak and government responses to it have created the ideal conditions for another public health crisis: a spike in domestic violence.
Historically, in times of strife such as war, natural disasters, and famine, rates of gender-based violence have soared. Early signs are indicating the same is true for the COVID-19 pandemic. In February, the peak of the coronavirus outbreak in China, police stations are reporting the number of domestic violence reports were up to three times higher than last year; and, in Lebanon, groups are reporting a 60 percent increase in domestic abuse cases since the pandemic began.
Social isolation, economic stressors, and fears of contracting a life-threatening illness in combination with mandatory stay-at-home orders that force abusers and their victims together for long periods of time have stoked fears that the number of domestic violence incidents will skyrocket in the United States.
On any given day in America, 20 people per minute are physically abused by an intimate partner. According to the New York Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence, nationally, one-third of women and one-quarter of men have experienced some form of physical violence at the hands of an intimate partner (spouse, ex-spouse, or boyfriend/girlfriend) in their lifetime. The possibility that conditions in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic will increase these already high numbers is troubling.
Reports vs. Incidents
Initial findings in a sample of US cities show that crime reports have largely decreased since the pandemic began. This includes police reports of domestic violence too, but often at a slower rate than other crimes. However, there are concerns that the reduction in reports does not reflect a true decrease in domestic violence incidents. Stay-at-home orders that require victims to be in close proximity to their abusers present new challenges for victims seeking to safely report violent incidents.
The diverging trends of increasing calls for support and a decrease in actual reports of domestic violence is troubling and suggests that victims may be delaying reporting until either they feel safe enough to do so or until a threatening situation escalates.
In New York City, when all of the Family Justice Centers temporarily closed to observe social-distancing orders, visitor traffic to NYC HOPE—a government-run website that provides resources to domestic violence victims—more than doubled. Between March 18 and April 5, the website averaged 115 unique visits a day compared to 45 visits a day prior to when the state’s stay-at-home order was instituted. The Violence Intervention Program, a shelter in New York City that serves primarily Latin American clientele, saw its call volume increase by 35 percent in March. In spite of the potential health risks of being in close proximity to others, the majority of the shelter’s uptick in calls came from survivors seeking refuge. There has been a sharp uptick in requests for restraining orders, too. Despite each of these trends, the number of reported cases of domestic violence in New York City over the same time period has fallen by nearly 40 percent.
Similar patterns are being reported across the country:
- In April, calls to the Connecticut Coalition Against Domestic Violence’s hotline went up by 52 percent;
- In Albany, New York, domestic violence calls to police have increased by nearly 30 percent since the lockdown began;
- In Seattle, calls increased by 22 percent in the first two weeks of March alone;
- In Chicago, domestic violence-related calls increased by 13 percent since last year but reports have gone down, meaning that despite an increase in violent incidents fewer victims are following through with filing complaints;
- In Austin, Texas, more calls expressing concerns of domestic violence are coming in from witnesses, like neighbors, rather than from the victims directly.
The diverging trends of increasing calls for support and a decrease in actual reports of domestic violence is troubling and suggests that victims may be delaying reporting until either they feel safe enough to do so or until a threatening situation escalates. Sometimes waiting can mean the difference between life and death, however. For instance, a report out of Canada notes that caseworkers are seeing threats of violence turn into acts of violence and that the severity of the abuse inflicted is worsening.
Firearms, Domestic Violence, and COVID-19
It is estimated that firearm sales in March 2020 increased by 85.3 percent from the year prior, concurrent with the spread of stay-at-home orders across America. With the exception of January 2013, the month following the mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut, there were more gun sales in March 2020 than at any time since the national firearm background check system was created 22 years ago.
Recently released statistics from the New York Police Department already show an increase in the number of domestic violence-related murders as of April this year when compared to the same period last year.
This increase in firearm sales adds an additional element of concern because when abusers have access to a gun they are five times more likely to kill their female victims. Guns are used to commit more than half of all murders of intimate partners, and every 16 hours an American woman is shot to death by her intimate partner. Nearly half of all female homicide victims are killed by a male intimate partner, and 82 percent of all homicide victims killed by an intimate partner are women. Additionally, The New York Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence notes that nearly 20 percent of all domestic violence incidents in the state involve a weapon.
It is not unusual for uncertain times, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, to coincide with an uptick in firearm purchases: gun sales also spiked after 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, and Hurricane Sandy. Still, more guns and higher rates of domestic violence have the potential to be a deadly combination. Recently released statistics from the New York Police Department already show an increase in the number of domestic violence-related murders as of April this year when compared to the same period last year, and globally there have been reports of increased gun-related domestic violence incidents.
Actions to Prepare for an Uptick in Domestic Violence
Actions taken by other countries and recommendations of those on the frontlines of this crisis offer options to help prepare for an increase in instances of domestic violence in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. These include the following:
- Create pop-up counseling centers in grocery stores, as some European countries are doing, because they have remained open throughout the shutdown and may offer an opportunity for victims to report incidents when they are away from their abusers.
- In France and Spain, domestic violence victims are encouraged to go to drugstores to seek help. They can either report the incidences to their pharmacists, who will then contact the authorities on their behalf, or, if they can’t speak freely, they can say a predetermined code word such as “mask 19,” which is the phrase being used in those countries. As pharmacies in New York have also been designated as “essential businesses” and remain open during the pandemic, a similar program could be implemented in this state.
- Traditional shelters typically cannot accommodate the required social distancing standards, so victims of domestic violence could be provided with a hotel room until a more stable living situation can be found, as is being done in France.
- Landlords and building managers could be encouraged to publicly post contact information for crisis hotlines and local women’s shelters. As most people are currently subject to stay-at-home orders, these postings could reach many potential victims.
- Additional funding for women’s shelters and sexual assault centers could be allocated so they can better prepare for an influx of new victims.
- Domestic violence officers could be required to reach out to known past victims of domestic violence and others who are deemed vulnerable to domestic abuse. Checking in on these vulnerable individuals could help to ensure their safety.
As noted, a surge in firearm sales has occurred along with the coronavirus outbreak. While New York is already on the forefront of gun violence intervention policy, this is not true for many states. To help prevent the intersection of the pandemic and a rise in firearm sales leading to a spike in domestic violence fatalities nationwide, policymakers in other states and at the national level can take a variety of actions regarding firearms. These include:
- Pass laws that restrict abusers’ access to firearms and ammunition including people convicted of misdemeanor stalking crimes, as has been done in New York. Such crimes are a strong predictor of future violence.
- Close the “boyfriend loophole” in every state, as New York has done. This gap in firearm regulations allows for domestic abusers that are not married to, living with, or have a child with their victim to still be allowed to own guns. The Protecting Domestic Violence and Stalking Victims Act/Zero Tolerance for Domestic Abusers Act, a federal proposal, would close this loophole across the country.
- Require that abusers provide proof that they have actually relinquished their firearms after the conviction of a domestic violence misdemeanor. This policy has been linked to a 16 percent reduction in intimate partner gun related homicides in states that have laws that require this after the issuance of emergency protective orders and final protective orders.
- A federal Universal Background Check law would require that a background check is performed before the sale of every gun, including sales by unlicensed private sellers. This will reduce legal access to firearms by those convicted of domestic violence crimes.
If you or someone you know needs help:
- Call: The National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). Advocates are available 24/7 and can provide help in more than 200 languages.
- Chat: The National Domestic Violence Hotline’s website, thehotline.org. The chat feature will allow you to speak discretely with an advocate.
- Text: The Crisis Text Line by texting HOME to 741741. The free services are available 24/7 and a text will connect you with a crisis counselor.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jacklynn Blanchard is graduate research assistant at the Rockefeller Institute of Government