Giving or Getting? New York's Balance of Payments with the Federal Government (2026)

Download Report

November 19, 2026

Executive Summary

Each year, trillions of dollars flow between the Federal government and the states, but not all states benefit equally. Some receive far more in federal spending than they pay in taxes, while others contribute substantially more than they get back. In its ninth annual analysis, the Rockefeller Institute of Government examines this redistribution by analyzing the balance of payments. A term popularized by the late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, the balance of payments refers to the net difference between Federal revenue collected from a state and Federal expenditures spent within that state. This report strives to shed light on both the source of these differences and how they have changed over time.

The Rockefeller Institute’s annual balance of payments (BOP) analysis is designed to aid policymakers as they deliberate whether there is too much redistribution of funding or too little. The consequences of budgetary decisions can have a profound impact on the economies of their states and the lives of their constituents. The report also explains how Federal policy, the economy, and emergency aid affect what each state pays and receives. This report presents detailed preliminary estimates of revenue and spending data for Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) 2024 and revised estimates for FFY 2023. While the analysis is national in scope, it focuses squarely on New York.

New York has historically been one of the largest contributors to Federal revenues, but prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the state’s return on those tax dollars consistently fell below that of virtually every other state. From 2015 through 2019, New York’s balance of payments averaged 49th among the states on a dollar basis and 48th per capita. The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted this pattern: New York posted large positive balances in 2020 and 2021, but saw its BOP fall back to a negative $6.3 billion in 2022 as Federal receipts grew and spending declined. Post-pandemic volatility continued to impact the state economy in 2023, causing New York’s balance to again turn positive as receipts fell while pandemic spending continued, albeit at a much lower level. The spending and revenue data now point toward a return to pre-pandemic norms. Preliminary data for FFY 2024 indicate a negative balance for New York of $18.6 billion and a ranking of 48th relative to other states. This result follows a revised positive balance of $13.6 billion for 2023 and a ranking of 25th.

Table 1. Average Annual Balance of Payments by Period, FFY 2015–2024
(Dollars in Millions)
Actual Excluding COVID-19 Spending
State Average BOP Rank Average BOP Rank
Alabama $43,872 9 $38,816 5
Alaska $7,837 34 $6,661 28
Arizona $44,716 8 $36,289 9
Arkansas $20,081 22 $16,868 22
California $27,416 19 -$32,305 50
Colorado $7,746 35 $1,274 38
Connecticut $4,215 40 -$96 41
Delaware $4,915 37 $3,678 33
Florida $66,987 4 $42,887 3
Georgia $43,308 10 $30,112 12
Hawaii $11,472 27 $9,580 25
Idaho $8,006 33 $6,271 30
Illinois $12,859 26 -$4,281 45
Indiana $27,005 20 $19,930 20
Iowa $10,725 29 $7,180 27
Kansas $9,618 31 $6,603 29
Kentucky $40,195 12 $35,314 10
Louisiana $33,121 15 $26,660 15
Maine $10,074 30 $8,487 26
Maryland $73,973 2 $66,684 2
Massachusetts -$2,562 49 -$12,248 47
Michigan $43,041 11 $29,533 13
Minnesota $4,695 39 -$2,025 44
Mississippi $29,217 17 $25,774 16
Missouri $37,894 13 $31,$496 11
Montana $6,211 36 $4,918 31
Nebraska $3,688 41 $1,554 37
Nevada $8,279 32 $4,089 32
New Hampshire $1,136 48 -$423 43
New Jersey -$15,785 50 -$28,058 49
New Mexico $27,835 18 $25,449 17
New York $11,054 28 -$22,338 48
North Carolina $49,347 7 $38,905 4
North Dakota $2,303 46 $1,159 39
Ohio $50,811 6 $37,305 7
Oklahoma $25,324 21 $21,210 19
Oregon $16,276 24 $11,403 23
Pennsylvania $55,232 5 $38,532 6
Rhode Island $4,765 38 $3,164 34
South Carolina $33,871 14 $28,668 14
South Dakota $3,600 43 $2,470 36
Tennessee $31,673 16 $24,525 18
Texas $69,240 3 $37,142 8
Utah $2,592 45 -$411 42
Vermont $3,610 42 $2,643 35
Virginia $100,819 1 $92,225 1
Washington $2,685 44 -$6,011 46
West Virginia $19,297 23 $17,392 21
Wisconsin $15,590 25 $9,629 24
Wyoming $1,842 47 $1,084 40

Note: Balance of payments equals Federal expenditures minus Federal receipts; positive values mean a state received more than it paid. “Excluding COVID-19 spending” subtracts Federal COVID-19 relief outlays from each state’s expenditures in every year, 2015–2024; receipts are unchanged. Ranks are among the 50 states (1 = largest positive balance).

Source: Rockefeller Institute of Government staff estimates.

New York’s reversal of fortune in 2024, including its 23-step drop in rank on a total dollar basis, was driven by a substantial increase in Federal revenue collections. Federal revenues collected from New Yorkers rose 11.4 percent between 2023 and 2024, slightly higher than the 11.1 percent increase in national collections allocable to the states. Because of New York’s large revenue base, the third largest of the 50 states, its 11.4 percent growth increased the state’s contribution to the Federal coffers by $36.6 billion in 2024. At the same time, Federal expenditures in New York grew only 1.3 percent, adding just $4.4 billion, with a $9.4 billion drop in COVID-19 relief spending offsetting most of the $13.8 billion increase in all other Federal spending in the state. The result is a $32.2 billion negative swing in New York’s balance of payments for 2024. The wind-down of pandemic aid thus contributed to that swing, though far less than the revenue increase. And because pandemic spending fell in every state, its decline did little to change New York’s relative ranking. Had COVID-19 spending in every state remained at 2023 levels, New York would have ranked 47th rather than 48th; and had receipts instead remained at 2023 levels, it would have ranked 26th, essentially unchanged from 25th in 2023.

The impact of Federal emergency COVID-19 spending, which previously had a profound impact on New York’s BOP position relative to other states, is now more firmly in the rearview mirror. Pandemic-related spending is estimated to have dropped to approximately $118 billion in FFY 2024, down from $222 billion in 2023 and a peak of nearly $1.8 trillion in 2021. Over the four years from 2020 through 2023, pandemic spending totaled $4.0 trillion (year-by-year figures for New York appear in the discussion of Table 4, and Tables 10 and 11 show each state’s balance over time). Because Federal pandemic recovery aid tended to be distributed commensurately with state population, New York’s share of Federal spending and its BOP position improved considerably.

Table 1 below presents the average annual balance of payments over the 10 years that the Rockefeller Institute has conducted this analysis and highlights the profound impact that the COVID-19 pandemic has had on New York’s balance of payments. The first two columns indicate that New York’s average dollar-value balance over the entire period is a positive $11,054 million, yielding a rank of 28th. Only two states, Massachusetts and New Jersey, are net donors on average over the period. But Table 1 also indicates that when pandemic funding is excluded from the analysis, New York’s BOP falls to a negative $22.3 billion and a rank of 48th. We conclude from these results that in the absence of the pandemic, New York would have consistently ranked at or near the bottom in all 10 years.

Although the Rockefeller Institute’s balance of payments analysis dates only to FFY 2015 in its current form, an examination of the available data for the period from 1998 through 2010 leads to the conjecture that prior to 2020, New York had posted positive balances only in 2009 and 2010, i.e., during and immediately following the Great Recession. That analysis leads us to conclude that for New York and a handful of other states (California, Illinois, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, and Washington), only a severe economic contraction can invert their typically net-donor status. The 2024 results presented in this report are consistent with this historical pattern.

Looking ahead, Treasury Department data indicate that total Federal receipts grew 6.4 percent in 2025, while budgetary spending grew 4.1 percent. New York State taxpayers likely made a substantial contribution to that revenue growth based on historical patterns. As a result, New York is likely to post another negative balance of payments for 2025 and to remain near the bottom next year and, barring yet another catastrophic event, for many years going forward.

Key findings from this year’s report include:

  • Based on preliminary data, New York posted a negative balance of payments of $18.6 billion and a ranking of 48th for 2024; this compares with a positive balance of $13.6 billion and a rank of 25th for 2023. The swing in New York’s balance of payments and ranking between the two years was a direct consequence of the swing from a decline in Federal revenue collected from state taxpayers to an increase, with the continued decline in pandemic-related spending playing a secondary role.
  • On a per capita basis, New York’s BOP swung from a positive $689 in 2023 to a negative $928 in 2024, resulting in a two-step drop in the state’s ranking from 45th in 2023 to 47th in 2024. The national average per capita balance of payments for 2024 was $3,283, meaning that New York received $4,211 less than the national average.
  • Across all states, allocable Federal receipts rose 11.1 percent in 2024, while total allocable expenditures increased by 3.6 percent. In New York, Federal receipts grew a slightly larger 11.4 percent, and Federal expenditures rose 1.3 percent. On a dollar basis, New York was the third largest contributor of revenue and the fourth largest recipient of Federal spending.
  • Nine states posted negative BOPs for 2024. The five states with the least favorable dollar balances in 2024 were New Jersey (-$33.7 billion), California (-$31.9 billion), New York (-$18.6 billion), Massachusetts (-$16.7 billion), and Washington (-$11.6 billion).
  • The five states with the most favorable dollar balances in 2024 were Virginia ($141.6 billion), Maryland ($81.6 billion), North Carolina ($54.8 billion), Pennsylvania ($54.5 billion), and Florida ($54.5 billion).
  • For every dollar New York sent to the Federal government in 2024, it received $0.95 in Federal expenditures. This compares with an average of $1.24 received for every dollar contributed across the 50 states. As a state with a high concentration of income and wealth, New York continued to contribute significantly more in receipts on a per capita basis ($17,809) than the national average ($13,939), a difference of $3,870.
  • The five states with the least favorable BOPs in 2024 on a per capita basis were New Jersey (-$3,550), Massachusetts (-$2,346), Washington (-$1,468), New York (-$928), and California (-$811).
  • The five states with the most favorable BOPs in 2024 on a per capita basis were New Mexico ($16,231), Virginia ($16,052), Alaska ($13,718), Maryland ($13,070), and West Virginia ($12,134).
  • New York’s expansive fiscal capacity is often cited as a reason for New York to subsidize other states, but this argument overlooks the extreme diversity of economic outcomes within the state and the equally diverse needs of its population. In 2024, New York’s poverty rate was 14.0 percent (12.1 percent nationally), 16.2 percent of its households received SNAP (11.8 percent nationally), and 29.1 percent of its residents had Medicaid or other means-tested coverage (20.5 percent nationally). The great wealth of a relative few easily masks that need.

Read the full report.

View the balance of payments data dashboard.